English
Español
Good afternoon everyone, it’s time to dive back into the mailbag and answer some of your questions. Remember to send in your questions for our weekly call by e-mail to pinstripealleyblog [at] gmail [dot] com.
Gary_Lambert asks:Is Jazz under or overrated?
Jazz Chisholm Jr. certainly made his mark last season, putting up a 30/30 campaign with a 126 wRC+ and 4.4 fWAR. That’s a very strong season, and it looks even better when you consider that he started out the year playing out of position at third base still while the Yankees tried to accommodate the last gasp of DJ LeMahieu’s tenure with the team. Once he made the shift back to second base, it was like flipping a switch on his defensive value: whether you’re looking at his OAA (-3 as a third baseman, 8 at second) or DRS (-4 at third, 2 at second) there was a major improvement.
Put all of that together, and the full package is a top five second baseman in the league, which is exactly where Chisholm ranked by fWAR. And just like Nico Hoerner and Ketel Marte, two of the few names that placed above him last year, he was subject to trade rumors for a portion of the offseason as the Yankees considered how to retool the offense. Those talks ultimately went nowhere, and we have no idea if the Yankees even seriously pursued any calls that came for their star infielder, but there were enough folks on the outside who seemed willing to hear out trading away Jazz ahead of his walk year.
I think a lot of Chisholm’s perception right now is tied to the additional discussion revolving around his future free agency. There’s a lot to speculate on with regards to how he’ll perform on a big-money deal and just how much he should get, whether teams will weigh his improvement in New York enough against his earlier days as a Marlin, and so on. But that’s all parts of a debate on how much to pay Chisholm into his 30s, not where he stands entering this season here and now. And with that in mind, I think Chisholm is a tad underrated compared to the skills he’s showcasing right now. It’s not a massive slight — I don’t think there’s anyone who would try and say Jazz isn’t in the top 10 or so — but there’s a real possibility that he ends up the best second baseman in baseball this year, and a strong one that he could finish in the top three. Only Hoerner showcased a balanced skillset like Chisholm did, flashing the glove as well as swinging an above-average bat, so if you had to bet on candidates to stick near the top those two stand out.
IndyAnaJones asks:What happened to the daily PSA thread ending with two questions for the fan base?
It’s not common that we get a question more directed at the site rather than about the team, but this one has an easy answer. We changed the format slightly, taking one question and giving a little bit of our own thoughts on it before posing the question towards you all — all while including the old gameday tune-in information and look ahead to what was on the site that day. You can find them at the start of the day just like the old Today on Pinstripe Alleys led off our daily coverage (here’s today’s edition for example). By all means, give us feedback on whether you like the adaptation!